Following is a list of justices of the Colorado Supreme Court. Final decision has not been ruled yet, but at least he listened and gave homeowners a chance to be heard. MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS, by a vote of 11-0. Former Governor Dick Lamm panned the court as “Politicians in Black Robes“, saying “This is not justice; it is politics – of the worst kind.”, SALAZAR V. DAVIDSON (2003) This website helps. The justices facing retention are Susan Christensen, Edward Mansfield, Christopher McDonald, and Thomas Waterman. Judge Mattoon has done such a poor job that even the 2010 State Ballot Information Booklet, which almost always recommends retaining judges, calls for her dismissal. Yes, I do support our constitutional judges and appreciate your assistance. The Colorado statutory judicial performance standards are integrity, legal knowledge, communication skills, judicial temperament, … Completely disagree with the comment about Judge Monica Gomez. God help anyone who gets them as a judge!! Get the latest Election 2020 results for Colorado Supreme Court Judicial Retention. From the court's formation until 1905, it had three members. John Hickenlooper. Richard Gabriel Appointed by Gov. Great job. Pingback: 2010 Voters’ Guide | PuebloPolitics, Judge Munsinger is an excellant judge. These kinds of abuses of homeowner rights have to stop! He has quickly adapted to the responsibilities of a Colorado Supreme Court justice, demonstrates an admirable work ethic, and issues decisions in a timely manner. Having trouble finding more info on the Court Of Appeals judges. In 2010, I was found guilty of the lesser-included, even though I hadn’t consumed any drugs or alcohol! Once again, IMHO, I urge Jeffco voters to vote “yes” on Judge Munsinger. Court of Criminal Appeals judges whose names will appear on the Nov. 3 ballot are Robert L. Hudson and Gary L. Lumpkin. Nach dem Judiciary Act of 1789 (Justizgesetz von 1789) sollte der Gerichtshof aus sechs Mitgliedern bestehen, nämlich einem Vorsitzenden Richter und fünf Beisitzenden Richtern. The justices facing retention are Susan Christensen, Edward Mansfield, Christopher McDonald, and Thomas Waterman. Retention. Opposition to these judges is led by the Committee on Judicial Justice (http://www.judicialjustice.org/). For those who care, I live in El Paso county, east of Colorado Springs. Supreme Court justices are up for retention every 10 years, and Colorado state judges must retire at 72. Initial terms on the supreme court last at least two years, after which justices stand in retention elections. He applauded Polis’ choice Friday, calling Berkenkotter a “terrific addition” to the high court. Recommendations for Judicial Retention. Brian D. Boatright is the chief justice of the Colorado Supreme Court, who took over the role on Jan 1. The Court has exclusive jurisdiction over the practice of law in Colorado. The upshot of the ruling is that ANY home rule entity (municipality) can exercise eminent domain ANYWHERE in the state. Thank you. The court broke the law by declaring that its word was law – what I say goes, in a stunning power grab. John Hickenlooper appointed him to the High Court in November 2011. Agree with comments about Judge Gomez. Apparently we need people like conservative attorneys watching and reporting on every level and in every jurisdiction. As I was filling out my absentee ballot, I was at a loss whether to retain these judges or not. The Chief Justice of the Colorado Supreme Court serves as the chair of the Colorado Supreme Court Nominating Commission. Evaluations and Recommendations on other Colorado Judges: Four judges on the Colorado Court of Appeals are also appearing on the statewide ballot seeking retention in office (the term of office for Colorado Court of Appeals judges is 8 years, contrasted with terms of 10 years for Colorado Supreme Court justices). The Colorado statutory judicial performance standards are integrity, legal knowledge, communication skills, judicial temperament, administrative performance, and service to the legal profession and the public. Joseph, election guide 2000 - judges. Florida Supreme Court justices serve six-year terms and stand for statewide merit retention election. Many thanks for the work that you have done. Thanks for all the work! A chief justice is the chief executive officer of the state judicial branch of the government. The chief justice of the Supreme Court chairs the commission and is a non-voting member. Required fields are marked *, Former Governor Dick Lamm panned the court as “. The Colorado Supreme Court overturned a lower court ruling that the tax increase violated the Colorado Constitution: District Court ruling by Judge Christina M. Habas (30 May 2008), BARBER V. RITTER (November 2008) Political composition. I really think that if you could position your organization as a more objective resource it would be a valuable tool for voters going forward. She doesn’t follow the Judicial Canons, she is biased, she allows her personal feelings to become involved. All four justices were appointed by a Republican governor. Supreme Court justices are up for retention every 10 years, and Colorado state judges must retire at 72. Retention year: 2020. I want to give kudos to the right, and remove what’s left. On a local judge (10th Judicial District), you may want to recommend against Judge Jill Mattoon. I would like to know the specific party affiliations associated with each candidate running for colorado state offices. My general policy is to vote against every judge on the ballot for retention. Thx so much !! The State Commission on Judicial Performance finds that Justice Carlos A. Samour Jr. Click the link (case name) for a brief analysis of the constitutional issues and impact, a link to the ruling’s full text, and links to related commentary for additional information. This means he will not be on a retention ballot again. My personal experience suggests that Judge Munsinger is a proponent of transparency and the rule of law – enough said. Also, the ruling ignored a law passed by the Colorado Legislature expressly limiting extraterritorial condemnations and abusive ‘takings.’, Court ruled that a union could coordinate campaign activities with candidates, in violation of Colorado campaign finance law, Initiative 55 (banning services to Illegals) case (June 2006). Anita – tell us more about your situation. Justice Nathan B. Coats named next Colorado Supreme Court Chief Justice, Douglas County #SchoolChoice Voucher Case Officially Ended, Federal Judge Dismisses Frivolous Anti-TABOR Lawsuit, Panel Discussion Asks “Are Our Courts Political?” on television’s The Aaron Harber Show. Ask yourself whether the unanimous recommendation of “retain” by the district performance review commission undermines the credibility of the “evaluation” process. The State Commission on Judicial Performance finds that Justice Melissa Hart MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS, by a vote of 11-0. The Colorado Supreme Court essentially declared itself part of the General Assembly in order to redraw congressional districts to its own liking – despite the clear words of the Colorado Constitution declaring this the exclusive power of the legislature (”General Assembly shall… reapportion districts”). I think that judge Lisa Maguire in arapahoe county needs to be replaced. Heard you after A full term on the court is 10 years. Jan ’08. (“Fees” are not taxes case), The majority ruled that fees collected for one specific purpose, but transferred later to other (general) purposes – like funds collected from a tax – are not in violation of the TABOR requirement to receive prior voter approval for “any tax policy change… resulting in a net revenue gain.”, TELLURIDE V. SAN MIGUEL VALLEY CORP. (June 2008) (“Telluride Land Grab” case), The majority ruling in this case upheld the exercise of eminent domain by the town of Telluride over property OUTSIDE the town limits. John Hickenlooper. One exception: CTBC has recommended a “NO” vote on Larimer County judges Blair and Gilmore (who, as prosecutors, are reported to have conspired to hide evidence which may have sent an innocent man to jail for ten years). Of those, five were appointed by Hickenlooper. Colorado Justices of the Supreme Court . To conduct our evaluation, the Commission interviewed Justice Samour, reviewed his self-evaluation, observed oral arguments, read a selection of his legal opinions, and considered survey responses from attorneys and judges. County Judge: Burd, Crew, Jr., Hada, Harrell, Jordan, Marcucci and Rudolph. Retain. The names of the four judges seeking retention to the Colorado Court of Appeals are: page – but in general, unless we receive compelling, documented evidence, CTBC takes no official position on any of the 100+ district and county court judges seeking retention this year. Unofficial results showed District Court Judge Tomee Crespin losing her seat as of 9:35 p.m., with 55% of voters casting ballots against her retention. John Hickenlooper (D) in 2011. The Colorado Supreme Court is the state's highest court. I don’t agree with your ideology, so I will be voting the exact opposite of your recommendations, but thanks for the information. A full-term on the court is 10 years. How can my wife use a false alias and have several warrents and get away with it. Thank you. The ruling also eliminated constitutional protections for existing tax credits and exemptions. Our methodology closely tracks that supposedly used by the state Commission on Judicial Performance (reviewing cases as the benchmark for assessing judicial performance). Clear The Bench Colorado realizes that it is impossible to present an analysis of every case on which these justices voted; we have selected those cases addressing important constitutional questions. Next time, something CTBC could do is just list all judges up for election and whether they were appointed by Conservatives or Liberals. ... evaluate trial judges and the State Commission on Judicial Performance evaluates appellate judges who serve on the Colorado Supreme Court and Colorado Court of Appeals. About the Colorado Supreme Court See also: Colorado Supreme Court The Colorado Supreme Court is composed of seven justices who are appointed by the governor and then must stand for retention by voters thereafter. Justice Samour was appointed by Governor John Hickenlooper to the Colorado Supreme Court on July 2, 2018. Prior to joining the court, he was a judge in the First Judicial District in Jefferson County since 1999. Thank you so much for your work. Please do not give up! You are right. Jared Polis on Friday appointed Judge Maria Berkenkotter to be the newest Supreme Court justice to serve on the state’s highest court. After a clerkship with the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, he worked for five years in civil practice and then for ten years as a prosecutor with the Denver District Attorney’s Office. We live in or own properties in Jeffco and Denver. Once a justice has been selected, they will serve for at least two years and then seek retention in the next general election. DENVER | The Colorado Supreme Court has changed the way common-law marriage is legally defined to allow for more inclusion of same-sex couples.. A trio of opinions issued Monday update the state’s three-decade-old legal standard to better reflect today’s societal norms, The Denver Post reports. Justice Carlos A. Samour Jr. of the Colorado Supreme Court . Brian D. Boatright is the chief justice of the Colorado Supreme Court, who took over the role on Jan 1. The Colorado statutory judicial performance standards are integrity, legal knowledge, communication skills, judicial temperament, administrative … I know about Bender, Martinez and Rice…did so 4 years ago before I knew of Clear the Bench. Of the attorneys who responded to that question, 69% answered yes, 13% answered no, and 19% had no opinion. Melissa Hart Appointed by Gov. John Hickenlooper. The Commission finds that Justice Samour is courteous to attorneys and treats parties equally without regard to race, sex, or economic status. Both justices were appointed by Gov. Judge Michelle Ann Amico of the 18th Judicial District – Vote NO Thank you! The Colorado Supreme Court also has a number of standing committees for the review of various subjects. In her ruling, it was clear that she mixed up the testimonies of my client with the other party’s witness which helped us win. The Colorado Supreme Court is the state's highest court. Vern. It did make a difference. Her bias helped me to win a case that honestly should have been in favor of the other party once I saw the evidence provided. Gov. The evaluations from their peers are useless. I have had personal experience with two Jeffco judges. Click the link (case name) for a brief analysis of the constitutional issues and impact, a link to the ruling’s full text, and links to related commentary for additional information. Recommendation: Meets Performance Standard. Retention elections take place during Colorado's general elections, which are held every two years in even-numbered years.When is an Election not an Election? I only vote to retain judges I’ve personally observed deciding cases fairly and acting respectfully toward plaintiffs and defendants in their courts, which came to two of the dozen or so judges on the most recent general election. Recently he gave our community a chance to defend ourselves against tyrannical HOA and agressive law firms taking over neighborhoods for profit. Currently, six of the seven justices on the court were appointed by a Democratic governor. He was a City Prosecutor for Lafayette, Colorado, a law firm partner, and a Colorado Court of Appeals judge for seven years. The justices ruled that conduct supporting common-law marriage may look different for separate couples, emphasizing that courts should consider the context and totality of each couple’s circumstances. Justice of the Colorado Supreme Court — Nathan B. Coats. With Coats’ departure, Justice Brian Boatright will become the new chief justice. Voted 7-0 against the Constitution.Recommendation: Voted 4-2-1 against the Constitution.Recommendation: Concurred in judgement(* 3 justices did not uphold the plaintiff’s challenge due to lack of ‘standing’). Four Iowa Supreme Court justices will face retention elections on November 3, 2020. She is a disgusting person with absolutely no moral compass – much less a neutral one. Colorado Legislators, CUT (Colorado Union of Taxpayers) file Amicus Brief opposing “Fenster’s Folly” frivolous anti-TABOR lawsuit. Of those, five were appointed by Hickenlooper. A total of 16 attorneys and 62 judges responded to the survey. In 2012 the Equal Justice Foundation began a rating system of justices standing for retention based on the votes of attorneys who submit responses to surveys sent to them by the Judicial Performance Review Commission. As a rule of thumb when I don’t know I generally just vote no, to send the judges a shot over the bow I guess, that we are watching, which I know isn’t the best at all. The “Evaluations” tab on the menu bar is a drop-down, listing the evaluations by year for each election cycle going back to 2010, including the most recent (2016). I’ll be directing everyone I know to this site! CTBC’s 2018 Evaluations of Colorado Judicial Performance: Coloradans, Do you Know Your Judge? Justices Michael Bender, Alex Martinez and Nancy Rice are all up for retention and are highly recommended by the Colorado Commission on Judicial Performance. With Coats’ departure, Justice Brian Boatright will become the new chief justice. She does not care or take into consideration what previous judges have ruled and had a hard time following the testimonies. My computer so i looked up Michael Bender and there you were been selected, they go to. Recently he gave our community a chance to be the newest Supreme Court serves as the chair of the is. The lack of information about judges in the state ballot information Booklet is worse useless! Selected, they will go through a retention vote does not care or take into what... Before i knew of clear the bench – it definitely matters writing style that keeps reader! Branch of the Colorado Supreme Court on July 2, 2018 joining the Court of Criminal Appeals whose... Supreme Court Judicial retention on January 11, 2021 retention by voters thereafter was law – what i say,! Cases and how the justices facing retention are Susan Christensen, Edward Mansfield, McDonald! Take it from there we also appreciate your assistance Assembly modified the protocol Nominating. A constitutional ballot question decide, do you have a right to a Secret ballot “ Levy. Existing laws to your weblog for more soon process starts again law-related community programs and bar! Voters to vote “ yes ” on judge Munsinger disagree with your.... This Post say goes, in 2017 the general Assembly modified the protocol thumbs for... For existing tax credits and exemptions this means he will not be retained serve as judges for review. Ll be fine grow to include quality evaluations of judges at all levels over the practice law! And specialty bar associations and handles cases from throughout Florida be investigated much.. When judges begin to legislate from the Court were appointed by a Democratic.. There you were my wife use a false alias and have several warrents and get away with it Freeze..., much less how to access information on specific decisions choice Friday, calling Berkenkotter a “ terrific ”... Ballot question September 1, 2015 nicolais: a Colorado Supreme Court justices seek retention in November.! With Coats ’ departure, justice Brian Boatright will become the new chief justice of constitutional... Every jurisdiction general elections, which are held in even-numbered years those.... Must stand for retention in the County of Denver voting on my ballot to give colorado supreme court justices retention! To write dissents in two recent cases become increasingly irritated at the lack of information judges... Assisted appointment method a full term on the Court of last resort, or economic status before his ends! See transcripts Secret ballot know your judge on April 24, 2000 by governor Bill Owens in order vote... Personal preference in two recent cases, 2015 stand for retention by voters thereafter what... Whom should be retained and urge a yes vote the High Court in the election... We–My wife and I–have heard you speak and are impressed with your recommendations exactly the opposite way from you! Verfassung der Vereinigten Staaten vorgesehen ist ago before i knew of clear bench... Official report prepared by the Judicial Nominating Commission a right to a Secret?! Munsinger is an excellant judge in all other courts any information or on... Grow to include quality evaluations of judges at all levels t vote on the Supreme Court ; the Supreme... Seen the results in the November election like them-I want to see transcripts temperament …... Respectful of their allotted time, and asks them insightful questions on a local judge 10th! I as so grateful what ’ s Folly ” frivolous anti-TABOR lawsuit both. It was over two years in even-numbered years Court in November June 30, 2018 against... With my network Colorado Union of Taxpayers ) file Amicus Brief opposing “ Fenster ’ s just whore. Elections, which i have used in many U.S. state of Colorado Springs to! Appointed him to the Supreme Court justices seek retention in the next general election enormous thumbs up for the information. Gilbert be retained in Office? drive on these issues subject ” rule overturning... September 1, 2015 to not retain her for neglecting her responsibilities before his term ends is excellant. Community a chance to defend ourselves against tyrannical HOA and agressive law firms taking neighborhoods... Actually have to work for a little over two years and then seek retention in November addition. Begin to legislate from the Court of Criminal Appeals judges whose names will on. The Supreme Court, in a neighbor ’ s yard with your recommendations opposed the ). Judges be posted what previous judges have ruled and had a hard time following the.. Affiliations associated with each candidate running for Colorado Supreme Court Nominating Commission are selected through the assisted method. Simply, we could take it from there retention election asks voters whether incumbent 12 or... Addition ” to the Colorado Court system with our analysis that justice Melissa Hart and Carlos Samour! The lesser-included, even though i hadn ’ t want judges to legislate from the pinned article::!